Episodes / Essentials: How Emotions & Social Factors Impact... /
Full transcript
Essentials: How Emotions & Social Factors Impact Learning | Dr. Mary Helen Immordino-Yang · 38:36 · 489 segments · transcribed with distil-large-v3 on Nov 17, 2026. Timestamps open the source at that second.
-
into and onto and mapping onto and then that's our life story?
-
Is that the way I think about it?
-
I mean, I think, yes, I think there's,
-
There's an awful lot of basic physiological mechanisms that become motivational mechanisms,
-
right, in all the senses, adaptive mechanisms that we share with all life forms.
-
What we basically are doing is taking these very primitive physiological regulatory
-
capacities that are essentially there to keep you alive.
-
And we conjure out of them a form of consciousness, an awareness of those processes that because
-
something that feels mentally powerful to us.
-
And then we start to build more and more facility,
-
more and more sort of wisdom around conjuring the story
-
that makes the most direct parsimonious sense out of
-
the things that you imagine somebody else may have experienced
-
given the complexities of the context in which they find themselves.
-
It becomes more and more dynamic, more and more sort of inferential.
-
This also goes back to what you were saying about
-
development. This is actually how I see development across the lifespan. My little two-year-old
-
loves the arm. Then she loves me as much as something else that she really appreciates like
-
daylight. And then she goes on from there. And when she's 80, God willing someday, right, she'll be
-
making a different kind of story, picking out things that matter in more subtle ways that other
-
people may not notice because of the historical context, because of her more lived experience
-
that she brings to that story, right?
-
So the things that become salient, the things you learn how to notice and build a story out
-
of are developmental, and they're learned across time.
-
But the basic fundamental processes around the emotions are always driving the need to make the story.
-
So when we are perceiving things, either very basic things like a visual scene or hugely complex,
-
elaborate things like Martin Luther King's speech, we are as much imposing onto the world our
-
own expectations of what is there as we are perceiving what's actually there, right?
-
So as we impose onto the world, we bring what you might call our cultural ways of seeing
-
and knowing our values and beliefs, and we push them onto the experience of what we
-
notice. So even in very basic ways, things like cultural values change the way in which
-
people observe and remember scenes, right? So, you know, there's classic work by Shinobu
-
Kittiyama and other people showing that in Japan versus in the U.S., when you show people
-
a scene of, you know, like an underwater scene with like all the beautiful things that are
-
underwater rocks and plants and things and little fish swimming by and then one big fish
-
What's this a picture of? They tend to talk about it's a scene of rocks and plants and little fish and then a big fish swims by. If you ask an American Western educated person, what is this a picture of? They say, oh, it's a fish swimming through a scene. He's shown that this is very, very automatic. It's very low level. It's perceptual, not just conceptual. And it actually changes what people actually notice in the scene and what they remember later and all that kind of stuff. We learn how to
-
sort of filter input. We're not little, you know, robots or little video cameras walking around
-
observing the world. And so when we see something as complex as a social story, we impose onto that
-
all kinds of personal experiences. So what we're really doing is moving through the world,
-
not in this kind of receptive, passive way, but we are actively imposing ourselves onto the world.
-
We're actively bringing our interpretive power and adapting what we do next relative to the way in which we accommodate, right?
-
Piaget talked about this 100 years ago, accommodate or assimilate those things into us that we, that may disagree with our schema, that may align in accord and reinforce them.
-
This matters a lot for the ways that humans experience the world more broadly because think about, for example, a terrible topic like Genesis.
-
or the Holocaust, right? How does something like that happen, right? How is it that people
-
who have empathy, who love their family, who love their neighbors, can suddenly turn on
-
each other, right? What's happened is they've shifted the way in which they narratize
-
the context of those events. The way in which they impose interpretation on somebody else's
-
pain has been fundamentally shifted from that's another human suffering to that's not a human
-
And that's a rat, a pig, a bug, or whatever it is, right?
-
And that dehumanization process allows us to shift our story set
-
so that we bring another set of values and beliefs into the space.
-
I'm just glad that you brought up this example
-
because I think that for a lot of people, it's inconceivable,
-
but I've never heard it framed the way that you're describing it,
-
which is that if the story becomes not about the other person's suffering,
-
but primarily about one's own story of suffering
-
and that can suppress or literally inhibit
-
the neural circuits that invoke empathy,
-
then it makes perfectly good neurobiological sense
-
as to why that would at least be possible.
-
And of course, I don't think it's a good thing.
-
It's just like many aspects of our biology and psychology,
-
it just happens to be the way things are.
-
It is.
-
And I think it really, I think, I mean,
-
I'm ever the opposite.
-
I'm also ever the educator, right?
-
I'm a teacher, I'm also very interested in the ways that we design educational experiences for young people.
-
I think the only hope we have to protect ourselves against these possibilities
-
is to systematically develop dispositions in ourselves,
-
proclivities within ourselves, to question our own motives
-
and to deconstruct our own assumptions about situations
-
and to engage with other people's perspectives systematically.
-
And when we develop those dispositions, the hope is that we are developing within
-
ourselves a kind of a veto system, right, a system for checking our own motivations against
-
other people's experiences of those motivations.
-
So much of what's leading, I think, though now we're going in another direction and
-
kind of a political direction, but so much what's leading us into these very divisive political
-
times, for example, not just, and the rise of authoritarianism, not just in the U.S., or the
-
threat of it, not just in the U.S., but around many places in the world, all of which, by the way,
-
are Western educated, is that we are taught that to know something means you own something
-
in yourself, and then you take that with you and you impose it on the world forevermore.
-
I know how to do algebra two and I can do it whenever you ask me kind of thing, and that's
-
what a good student is, where when people learn to engage with their own knowledge states in
-
more curious, open-minded, flexible ways, then we dispositionally teach ourselves to check our
-
assumptions, to rethink what we think we know, and, and this is key, developmentally, to
-
notice when we need to do that and when we should just plow ahead and it's totally fine.
-
And so what we're doing, I think, right now to ourselves, both in the education system and in things like social media, is we're reinforcing our own biases by diving down rabbit holes where you rehear the same thing over and over again that reinforces your own belief systems.
-
And then you come to believe those things and those puts you on a train toward a particular kind of action or belief system that never becomes deconstructed.
-
And it's very comfortable and it's easy to do.
-
But the responsibility I think we have as individuals and as groups, as humans, given the amazing intelligence we have, is to rise above that and actually look back on our own selves reflectively and deconstruct our preferences, deconstruct our values and our beliefs and systematically query them specifically around how they impact or influence or change the situations of those around us or don't.
-
don't, right, the situations and sustainability of the world that supports us or don't.
-
And so it all comes back to the emotions that drive our thinking.
-
So we have these very basic primitive physiological states which vary across individuals, the degree
-
to which they are, you know, incredibly powerful, easily evoked versus not, you know, there's
-
a lot of range in that.
-
Now all of that variation makes things interesting, right?
-
It's our ability to learn to experience those and to know, develop wisdom around when we need to query our own emotions and deconstruct the narratives that we're using to validate or substantiate those kinds of emotions in order to assess whether we actually are right, whether we should continue or whether we should step back and reframe.
-
Right?
-
And so that kind of mental flexibility really comes out of an emotional disposition.
-
It is our ability, so it takes it back to what you're asking at the very beginning.
-
It is our ability to not just drive from what feels like the bottom up, which of course
-
is always starting on the top down because you've got some interpretation of the world
-
that makes you feel fear, that makes your body do this, that makes you, right?
-
But also to be able to rise above, to transcend and think about what are the broader systemic
-
historical, ethical, civic implications of this narrative I'm telling myself, which feels
-
default like the truth.
-
And how might I deconstruct those systematically?
-
And how might I invite others to give me their version of those events and engage with
-
those systematically in order to be able to really appreciate the implications of my beliefs?
-
So the bottom line is that the emotions that we're talking about today are actually
-
the fundamental drivers of all of our thinking, decision-making, relationship building,
-
right, our community lives and our personal well-being all in one mix. But that doesn't kind
-
of excuse us for acting on their request. It actually imbues us with a responsibility to then
-
develop dispositions to systematically query those and reframe them when they are not serving us or the world.
-
well.
-
I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge our sponsor, AG1.
-
I'm excited to share the AG1 has just launched their newest formulation, AG1 Pro.
-
AG1 Pro takes the clinically backed AG1 formula, which is a blend of vitamins, minerals,
-
probiotics, and adaptogens, and adds three important new ingredients, creatine monohydrate,
-
calcium, HMB, and zinc carnacine.
-
Each serving has 5 grams of creatine monohydrate to support muscle strength and performance,
-
as well as brain health.
-
Calcium HMB to support muscle recovery
-
and reduce muscle breakdown
-
and zinc carnacine to support and improve
-
the lining of your gut.
-
All three of these ingredients
-
have compelling science to support them,
-
and therefore I love seeing them added
-
to the existing AG1 formula.
-
As most of you know,
-
I've been taking AG1 every day
-
for nearly 14 years now.
-
I started taking it long before
-
I even knew what a podcast was.
-
It's a great product,
-
and it's now made even better
-
with the new AG1 Pro formula.
-
If you would like to try AG1 Pro,
-
you can go to drinkag1.com slash Huberman to get a special offer.
-
AG1 is giving away a free bottle of omega-3 co-enzyme Q-10 with your first subscription.
-
Again, go to drinkag1.com slash Huberman to get a free bottle of omega-3 co-enzyme Q10
-
with your first AG1 subscription.
-
What do you think can be done at a concrete level in terms of education of younger people,
-
as well as education of people who are out of high school and,
-
beyond to try and adopt these more encompassing modes of learning and experiencing the world.
-
I think one really important step that as society will have to take or we won't make it.
-
And I know that sounds a little dramatic, but I actually think it's true,
-
is that we need to really get brave about how we think about the process of educating our young people